How Often Do Auto Accident Settlements Exceed Policy Limits in Colorado?

How often do auto accident settlements exceed the policy limits in Colorado? It’s a question we hear often, and the answer isn’t always straightforward. In many cases, insurance companies are only obligated to pay up to the coverage outlined in the at-fault driver’s policy. However, there are circumstances—such as multiple parties being liable, the existence of umbrella coverage, or an insurer acting in bad faith—where an injured person may be able to recover more than the stated policy limits. These are exceptions rather than the rule, but they can make a significant difference for someone facing steep medical expenses, lost income, and long-term care needs. At Dormer Harpring, our Denver car accident attorneys have helped individuals across Colorado navigate these complex situations by uncovering all potential sources of compensation and fighting for what our clients truly need to recover. Every accident is different, and understanding your legal options starts with knowing the boundaries—and exceptions—of the insurance system.

Understanding Auto Insurance Coverage & Policy Limits in Colorado

In Colorado, all drivers are required to carry minimum liability coverage. According to the Colorado General Assembly, the current mandatory minimum coverage includes $25,000 for bodily injury per person, $50,000 per accident, and $15,000 for property damage. While this may seem sufficient, a serious car accident can lead to damages well beyond these thresholds.

Auto insurance policies also vary based on optional coverages, such as uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage. These extra protections may come into play if the at-fault party’s policy doesn’t fully cover your losses. The real challenge arises when a settlement needs to go beyond these policy limits due to the severity of the injuries or the legal nuances involved in the case.

According to Colorado, drivers are strongly encouraged to carry more than the state minimum. Yet many drivers stick to the bare minimum, leaving injured victims in a difficult financial position after an accident.

How Can Auto Accident Settlements Exceed Policy Limits in Colorado?

Yes, in some cases, auto accident settlements can exceed policy limits in Colorado. However, achieving this outcome isn’t typical and generally depends on several complex legal and factual circumstances. To pursue compensation above policy limits, a claimant must often demonstrate that additional coverage applies or that the insurance company failed in its obligations. For instance, multiple liable parties may each hold separate insurance policies, allowing for a larger combined recovery. Similarly, if the at-fault party carries an umbrella policy, it may provide further funds beyond the primary policy’s cap. Another important scenario arises when an insurer acts in bad faith, delaying or denying a valid claim without justification. In these cases, courts may permit recovery that exceeds standard limits. These nuanced and fact-specific legal strategies require careful evaluation and assertive negotiation. Working with an experienced attorney can significantly improve your ability to uncover these opportunities and build a case for fair compensation that reflects the true extent of your losses.

Umbrella Policies and Their Role in Exceeding Limits

Umbrella insurance policies may provide additional compensation when the at-fault party’s primary policy is exhausted. These secondary coverages are typically purchased by individuals with substantial assets to shield themselves from high liability. If the negligent driver carries such a policy, you may be able to file an additional claim for further compensation. Identifying an umbrella policy, however, often requires thorough investigation and persistence.

Multiple Defendants and Their Impact on Your Settlement

If more than one party is liable for the accident, each may have separate insurance coverage, potentially increasing your total recovery. For instance, in a multi-vehicle pile-up or a commercial trucking accident involving both the driver and the company, victims might seek compensation from multiple insurers. Determining shared fault and policy availability is complex, but it can open up pathways to settlements above individual policy limits.

Bad Faith Insurance Claims and How They Affect Settlements

Insurance companies in Colorado are obligated to act in good faith when evaluating and settling claims. If an insurer unreasonably delays or denies a valid claim, you may have grounds for a bad faith lawsuit, which could result in compensation beyond the policy limits. This often applies when a claim’s value clearly exceeds the policy limits, and the insurer fails to settle within limits despite clear liability.

For example, if an insurer rejects a reasonable settlement demand and the injured party later secures a much larger jury award, that insurer might be liable for the full judgment, even if it exceeds the coverage. These claims require strong documentation and legal expertise.

Key Considerations When Settling Beyond Policy Limits

Pursuing compensation above policy limits isn’t automatic—it’s a strategic effort. Here are a few key considerations:

• Severity of injuries: Catastrophic or life-altering injuries can justify seeking compensation beyond the basic policy limits provided by an insurance company.
• Documented damages: Detailed records of medical costs, missed wages, and long-term care needs help support a settlement above the available coverage.
• Timely legal action: Colorado law gives you up to three years from the date of the crash to file a personal injury claim in most situations.
• Negotiation leverage: A compelling claim supported by facts and a credible trial threat can prompt an insurer to offer a higher settlement.
• Liability clarity: Insurers may be more inclined to settle above limits when there is overwhelming proof that another driver caused the accident.

Colorado also follows a modified comparative negligence rule, which means your compensation could be reduced if you’re found partially at fault. If you’re more than 50% responsible, you may not recover anything. This legal nuance affects how settlement values are calculated and negotiated.

Need Help with Your Colorado Auto Accident Claim? Contact a Local Lawyer Today!

Navigating the question of how often auto accident settlements exceed the policy limits in Colorado depends on the specific facts of your case and the legal pathways available. While exceeding policy limits isn’t common, it’s certainly possible under the right conditions. If you or a loved one has been seriously injured in a car accident, it’s worth exploring every option.

At Dormer Harpring, our Car Accident Lawyers take pride in helping Colorado accident victims pursue the compensation they deserve. Whether it’s negotiating with insurers, uncovering hidden policies, or pursuing bad faith claims, our legal team is ready to stand by your side.

Schedule a free consultation with our Denver-based team today and get answers tailored to your unique situation.

Check Out More Helpful Articles

• What Are Compensatory Damages?
• Can I file a car insurance claim without a police report?
• How to file a diminished value claim